How to Choose an SEO Agency, and the Questions to Ask

To choose an SEO agency, decide who should do the work, then hold every candidate to the same questions: who does the work, what you own, how they report, what they measure and what they will not do. This guide also covers how an agency compares with an in-house hire or a fractional CMO, the red flags, and what the first 90 days should look like.

The short answer

  • Pick the shape of help first: an agency for hands-on work, an in-house hire for a full-time role, a fractional CMO for senior direction across everything.
  • Walk away from guaranteed rankings, secret methods, and any setup where you do not control your own accounts.
  • Ask the same questions of every candidate, then judge the answers, not the pitch deck.

Agency, in-house or fractional CMO: when each fits

Settle the shape of help first. The question behind "marketing agency vs in house" is who does the work and who answers for the result. A third option sits between them: a fractional CMO, a senior marketer who works for you part time.

AgencyIn-house hireFractional CMO
Best fitYou know what you need done and want a team to do itMarketing is a steady, full-time job in your businessYou have several vendors or channels and nobody senior owning the plan
Who answers for resultsUsually its own channel (SEO, ads)You, through that personYour whole marketing plan and budget
Hands-on workYes, from a team of specialistsYes, but one person's skillsVaries. Some run channels themselves, some direct others
CommitmentA contract. Terms vary, so askA full-time employeeOften a monthly retainer
Watch out forReports that measure its own work, not your revenueOne person cannot be expert at everythingStrategy with no one doing the work

An agency is the right call when the job is clear, such as fixing a site's search problems or running Google Ads. An in-house hire fits when you have enough steady work to fill a role. A fractional CMO fits when the real problem is that no one senior owns the plan, and the agency question is one piece of it. Our post on what a digital strategy consultant actually does covers that last case in more depth.

Also be honest about whether you need anyone. Google says that if you run a small local business, you can probably do much of the work yourself. If your site is simply not showing up, start with why a website is not showing up on Google before you pay for help.

Red flags when you hire an SEO agency

Google's Search Central page "Do you need an SEO?" is the most useful public checklist. These are the red flags we would act on.

Walk away if you hear any of these

  • A guaranteed ranking. Google: "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." It also says that if an SEO guarantees first place, "find someone else." The same goes for a "special relationship" with Google or a "priority submit."
  • Secret methods. Google says to be careful if a company "is secretive or won't clearly explain what they intend to do," and notes that "you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire." If they cannot explain it, you carry the risk.
  • No access to your own accounts. You should never be locked out of your Search Console, analytics or site. Google advises granting only read access to Search Console during an audit, and says an SEO with FTP access "should be willing to explain all the changes they are making."
  • A long lock-in with no exit. Any contract that is hard to leave, or silent on who keeps the work if you do, deserves a second read.
  • Link schemes. Google: "You should never have to link to an SEO," and it calls link popularity schemes and mass search engine submissions "typically useless exercises."

Questions to ask on the first call

Ask every candidate the same questions and write the answers down. Several come from the interview list on Google's page. Each one comes with what a good answer sounds like.

Who will actually do the work?

Ask who writes, who fixes the site and who you talk to, by name. Some agencies sell with a senior person and hand the work to someone new.

Listen for: Named people, and a clear line between in house and outsourced work.

Who owns the accounts, the content and the data?

Your Search Console, Google Analytics and Google Business Profile should be in your name, with the agency added as a user. Your site and content stay yours if you leave.

Listen for: "You own everything." Be wary of any answer that routes your accounts through theirs.

How will you report, and how often?

Google's own list asks whether the SEO will share every change they make and explain the reasoning. Ask to see a real report with the client details removed.

Listen for: A written change log in plain English. A traffic dashboard with no explanation is not a report.

What will you measure, and what results do you expect?

Google lists "How do you measure your success?" as a question to ask. For most businesses the answer should be leads, calls, bookings or sales, with rankings in support. Google says changes can take "a few hours" or "several months," so expect a range.

Listen for: Targets tied to your revenue, and a realistic range, not a date.

What will you not do?

A good agency can name tactics it refuses to use, such as buying links, mass producing thin pages or anything that breaks Google's spam policies.

Listen for: A confident no, with reasons. Hesitation here is information.

Can I talk to past clients?

Google recommends asking for examples and checking references: was the SEO easy to work with, and did it produce results? Ask for one client who left, not only current ones.

Listen for: Specific examples with context, and references they are happy to connect.

How does the contract end?

Ask the notice period, who keeps the work if you leave, and whether you can exit after an initial term.

Listen for: Month to month after an initial term, or clear exit terms in writing.

What a good first 90 days looks like

A good agency does not promise a result in 90 days. It shows you steady work and a clear decision point. Google's SEO starter guide says changes can take hours or several months to show up, and suggests waiting a few weeks to assess the effect. So judge the first quarter on work and signals, not on rank.

  1. Days 1 to 30Access and a baseline. Accounts are set up in your name, current leads and calls are recorded, and the site is checked for problems that stop pages being found.
  2. Days 31 to 60Fixes ship. The agency makes the highest priority fixes and improves or adds the pages that matter most, with a written change log.
  3. Days 61 to 90The first honest report. It shows what changed, what moved, what has not yet and what is next, measured against the leads and sales from day one.
  4. Day 90A decision. Keep going, change the plan or stop. You should be able to leave with your accounts and work intact.

Where to start this week

  • Today: write down what you want from search in one sentence, in business terms (calls, bookings, quotes), and check you hold the admin login to your Search Console, analytics and Google Business Profile.
  • This week: shortlist two or three candidates and send each the same questions above before you take any call.
  • Before you sign: get the contract term, exit terms and account ownership in writing, and ask for a 90 day plan.

No pitch deck

Want a second opinion on your marketing?

Tell us what you are working on. We review every request, and the ones that are a fit get a link to book a call. If you are weighing an agency against a fractional CMO, we will tell you which we think fits.

Request a review of your account

Prefer not to talk first? The AI Visibility Audit is a one-time report that shows who ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Google AI Overviews name for your buyers' questions.

Common questions

How do I choose an SEO agency?

Decide first whether an agency is the right shape of help. Then interview two or three of them with the same questions: who does the work, what you own, how they report, what they measure, what results to expect and what they will not do. Check references, and walk away from anyone who guarantees rankings.

How do I hire a marketing agency?

Start with the outcome you need, such as more calls or bookings. Ask for a first 90 day plan before you sign a long contract, make sure you own every account, and agree in advance how you will judge whether it is working.

Marketing agency vs in house: which is better?

It depends on volume. An agency gives you a team of specialists without hiring each one. An in-house hire knows your business deeply, but is one person with one set of skills. Many small businesses start with an agency and hire in house once the work is steady enough to fill a role.

What is the difference between a fractional CMO and a marketing agency?

An agency is usually accountable for its own channel, such as ads or SEO. A fractional CMO is a senior marketer who is accountable for your whole marketing plan and budget, works part time, and can direct your agencies. Some businesses use both: the agencies do the work and the fractional CMO holds them to one number.

Can an SEO agency guarantee page one?

No. Google's Search Central says "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." Honest agencies promise a process, a plan and reporting, not a position.

Do I need an SEO agency at all?

Not always. Google says that if you run a small local business, you can probably do much of the work yourself, and it points to its SEO starter guide. An agency earns its fee when you lack the time or skills for it.

Sources

Next
Next

AEO vs. GEO vs. SEO: What’s Different and What You Actually Need